Rian Johnson doesn’t just shuffle the deck in his third Benoit Blanc mystery—he swaps out the entire card table. Wake Up Dead Man: A Knives Out Mystery is a gothic, God-haunted whodunit that trades yachts and country estates for pews, parish halls, and a town where the sacred and the suspicious share a fence line. Daniel Craig’s laconic sleuth wanders into his most treacherous maze yet, and the result is a film that feels at once braver, stranger, and more purposeful than its predecessors.
A whodunit dressed as a miracle
The hook is irresistible: an “impossible” killing tied to a small-town church, the kind of case that begs to be mistaken for a miracle—until Benoit Blanc mutters that it’s “just a murder,” and murders are what he solves. That framing yanks the series into new thematic territory. Where Knives Out skewered class and Glass Onion lampooned tech-bro egos, Wake Up Dead Man is preoccupied with faith, guilt, and the ways communities hide behind ritual when they can’t face the truth. It’s Johnson aiming for Chestertonian mystery with Poe’s fog at the edges—and he nearly gets there.
We meet Reverend Jud (Josh O’Connor), a bruised ex-boxer turned priest who stumbles into a parish ruled by a charismatic monsignor (Josh Brolin). When the monsignor ends up dead in a locked-room scenario, Jud’s past and present collapse into suspicion. It’s a deliciously theatrical setup for Blanc, who arrives as a man of reason in a town that prefers portents. The suspects? A pew’s worth: a vigilant church lady (Glenn Close), a flinty police chief (Mila Kunis), a tightly wound attorney (Kerry Washington), a celebrity physician (Jeremy Renner), a brooding author (Andrew Scott), a prodigy cellist (Cailee Spaeny), and more. The ensemble is stacked, but Johnson keeps their motives legible, their alibis slippery, and their secrets sticky.
The tone shift: from cozy to gothic
Johnson’s smartest play is tonal. The first film felt like a cozy fireside puzzler; the second, a fizzy vacation caper. This one? Candle smoke and stone—storm clouds stitched into the score. Craig gets to lower his voice and slow his gait; he’s less bemused observer and more weary pilgrim, stripping superstition from the evidence one fiber at a time. The film leans harder into atmosphere than quip density, and it pays off: the church becomes a labyrinth, the graveyard a ledger, and even the choir loft a place where harmonies can’t hide discord.
Yet it’s still fun. Johnson’s puzzle-box storytelling—red herrings that flip into clues, clues that collapse into new questions—remains intact. When the mechanism finally clicks, it delivers that special Knives Out pleasure: the thrill of seeing that it was all there, right in front of you, just artfully misdirected. Early reactions call it the darkest and most intricately layered entry; the description fits.
Daniel Craig, recalibrated
Craig’s Benoit Blanc has always walked a fine line between caricature and character. Here he tilts decisively toward the latter. The drawl is still honeyed, but his patience is thinner, his empathy harder-won, and his curiosity more dangerous. He looks like a man who knows that explanations may not bring anyone peace—and that sometimes they bring the opposite. It’s the richest Blanc Craig has played, and the supporting cast rises to meet him. O’Connor, in particular, threads grace and shame in a way that makes Reverend Jud feel tragic before we know why.
Spaeny’s musician gets standout comic beats (she reportedly trained for the cello business and makes it sing), while Close and Washington wield silence like weapons. Renner—whose hot-sauce gag cameo in Glass Onion became meme canon—comes back as an actual person, and he’s sly enough to make you forget the meta-joke.
“Impossible crime” mechanics, spiritual stakes
Knives Out movies have always been “howdunit” as much as “whodunit,” but this outing dances closer to the subgenre of impossible crimes. The parish murder seems to defy physics and probability; Johnson uses that impossibility to smuggle in questions about belief. When evidence appears to contradict common sense, what do people choose? Faith in a higher order—or in a human lie? The script has fun teasing miracle-hungry locals while never sneering at sincere devotion. That balance—skeptical, not cynical—gives the film a moral spine.
.jpg)
Craft that preaches without preaching
Longtime collaborators Steve Yedlin (cinematography) and Nathan Johnson (score) return and flex. Yedlin’s images render candlelight as something with weight; shadows feel like testimony that hasn’t yet been taken. Johnson weaves ecclesiastical textures into propulsive motifs—hymnal echoes tumbling into ticking clocks—which nudge the film toward a liturgical thriller. Those choices, paired with production design that makes the church a character, do half the storytelling before Blanc opens his mouth. (You’ll want a second viewing just to track where the camera tells the truth while the characters lie.
How it plays against the previous two
If Knives Out was a class satire in Agatha Christie drag and Glass Onion a tech satire in beachwear, Wake Up Dead Man is a parable. Each film sharpens Blanc by rubbing him against a different institution: wealth, celebrity, and now the church—read broadly, the social machinery that organizes our moral lives. The trilogy (so far) is less about one detective than about the worlds that insist they don’t need one. This chapter argues that piety and power are poor roommates, and that the story people tell about a “miracle” is often the tidiest way to stop asking hard questions.
The “why now” of it all
It’s not subtle that Johnson chose to premiere this entry in early fall festival season, then roll it into a brief theatrical window before streaming in December. The case is winter-dark; the themes are holiday-adjacent (sin, confession, forgiveness), and audiences will be primed for a communal mystery that argues for reason without ridiculing belief. Strategically, it’s smart counter-programming: an adult-aimed crowd-pleaser that isn’t a sequel about capes or kaiju, but still feels like an event. The plan: a limited theatrical run beginning November 26, then Netflix December 12. Pencil in two viewings—one for the plot rush, one for the craft.
Does it clear the bar?
The early consensus: yes, and with room to spare. Some call it the best of the series; others, at least the boldest. What’s certain is that Johnson refuses to repeat himself. He stretches tone without snapping the brand and trusts his audience to follow him into the fog. By the time Blanc gathers the flock for the explanation, the solution lands with both intellectual satisfaction and something like a moral afterglow. The film respects the cost of truth.
.jpg)
Little sweets in the candy box (no spoilers)
Locked-room pleasures. The film stages its centerpiece crime with stage-magician precision. You’ll argue with friends about angles and timings until the credits stop scrolling.
Choir-loft humor. Even in a darker register, Johnson can’t resist the throwaway gag that detonates two beats later. Keep your ears on the hymn lyrics.
A line you’ll quote. Blanc delivers an aphorism about “dressing a miracle” that will be clipped, captioned, and memed by Tuesday morning.
The verdict
Wake Up Dead Man is the rare threequel that expands the map and deepens the legend. It proves the Blanc films aren’t just clever contraptions; they’re flexible parables about the stories people tell to get through the night—and the detectives who turn on the lights anyway. In a cultural moment that often confuses certainty with truth, Johnson offers something better: a method. Observe, doubt, verify, and—when the miracle dissolves—name what really happened.
Craig’s sleuth has never been sharper, the ensemble never more finely tuned, the world-building never more intoxicating. If the first film made you a fan and the second made you a believer, the third might make you a witness.
See it in theaters November 26, then stream it December 12. Bring your best alibi.
SEO keywords: Wake Up Dead Man review, Knives Out 3 review, Daniel Craig Benoit Blanc, Rian Johnson mystery, gothic whodunit, TIFF 2025, Josh O’Connor priest, Netflix release December 12.
.jpg)
.jpg)
0 Comments