If you’ve felt a seismic shift rumbling under Studio 8H, you’re not imagining it. As Saturday Night Live gears up for Season 51, the show is making one of its boldest retools in years—ending the run of its hugely popular “Please Don’t Destroy” pre-tapes as we’ve known them, welcoming a fresh wave of cast members, and saying goodbye to some familiar faces on both the cast and writing staffs. The result? A season designed to feel different on purpose, with clear signals from the producers that the 50th anniversary was a celebration—and the 51st is a reset.
The end of a defining mini-era: No more PDD videos (as we knew them)
For the last few seasons, “Please Don’t Destroy”—the trio of Ben Marshall, John Higgins, and Martin Herlihy—became SNL’s reliable jolt of Gen-Z chaos: fast, absurd, and ultra-shareable videos that frequently dominated social feeds on Sunday mornings. Season 51 will officially close that chapter. The trio isn’t continuing on the show as a video unit: Ben Marshall has been promoted to on-air cast, John Higgins is exiting the show to pursue acting, and Martin Herlihy is staying—but on the writing staff. In other words, no more trio-driven digital shorts that defined so many recent cold-opens and mid-show pivots.
That doesn’t mean the tone PDD popularized disappears overnight—Marshall’s move to the cast could seed a new flavor of live sketches with the same quick, self-aware energy. But as a consistent pre-tape brand inside the show, “Please Don’t Destroy” is winding down.
Five new faces—and one very familiar one—in the cast
To fill out a reshaped ensemble, SNL is adding five performers for Season 51:
Ben Marshall (yes, that Ben Marshall), stepping up from the writers’ room to the main cast
Kam Patterson, a stand-up with crowd-work fluency and a growing online footprint
Veronika Slowikowska, an emerging multi-hyphenate with alt-comedy bona fides
Tommy Brennan, late-night–tested stand-up with crisp observational chops
Jeremy Culhane, a sketch/character player with digital-native instincts
This quintet is strategically diverse in style: one sketch-first writer-performer, two stand-ups, a character comedian, and a digital-platform cross-over—all great raw material for a modern SNL that lives simultaneously on TV and in the algorithm.
Who’s departing—and why it matters
Change on SNL is cyclical, but the scope this time is notable. The show is moving on from several cast members, including Heidi Gardner—a core utility player for eight seasons—and Michael Longfellow, Devon Walker, and Emil Wakim. That’s a meaningful reshuffle of both veteran glue and newer voices. Reports around the exits suggest a broader, top-down refresh, with producers intent on shifting the show’s rhythm after the 50th-season celebrations.
Behind the scenes, the writing staff is also changing. John Higgins (from PDD) is leaving, while Celeste Yim and Rosebud Baker—both with distinct, award-recognized sensibilities—are out as well. This inevitably affects the show’s sample platter of tones: Yim’s sharp point of view and Baker’s joke density brought variety to the update desk and beyond. Expect the new season to test different comedic gears as fresh writers and writer-performers settle in.
Who’s back—and what that signals
Amid the churn, some stabilizers remain. Season 51 will continue with core anchors and long-tenured stars (including the show’s longest-serving player), preserving the steady hand the series needs whenever it turns over big chunks of the roster. That continuity at the top—especially on “Weekend Update”—gives newer cast members runway to experiment without the entire show wobbling week to week.
One more clear signal from leadership: James Austin Johnson—whose uncanny political impressions often set the season’s mood—is confirmed to return, which helps maintain the show’s headline-chasing engine during a newsy year.
Premiere date and the strategy behind the timing
SNL’s Season 51 premiere is scheduled for October 4, 2025. That timing—just after the fall TV ramp-up—suggests the show wants its “new era” narrative to land squarely when audiences are re-forming their weekly viewing habits. Expect a premiere that showcases the rookies early, a statement pre-tape to outline the season’s vibe, and perhaps a cold open that lets JAJ cook.
.jpg)
What the creative chessboard looks like now
Here’s how the pieces likely move with PDD’s video era ending and the cast shuffle in place:
Live-sketch emphasis: Without the guaranteed viral PDD short each week, the show may lean harder on live material—and place more bets on pre-tapes from other in-house voices. That means new film units or break-out pairings could emerge by midseason.
Update stays the metronome: With experienced anchors holding court, “Weekend Update” will continue to be the clockwork segment anchoring each show—critical when other variables are in flux.
A wider lane for new character ecosystems: Ben Marshall’s move to the cast can seed recurring worlds that previously lived in PDD’s office-video format—but now, live. Pair him with the new character comics (Slowikowska, Culhane) and one of the veteran straight-men, and you have a recipe for quick recurring hits.
Digital distribution will still drive discovery: Even without PDD’s branded shorts, the show’s clip economy remains vital. The rookies’ stand-up and internet pedigree suggests SNL will continue tailoring material for snackable next-day clips that work on TikTok, Reels, and YouTube.
Winners, risks, and what to watch for
The winners in the short term are viewers who crave novelty. A big cast reset forces SNL to take swings: unexpected host pairings, brand-new recurring characters, and different comedic registers at 12:50 a.m. This is when strange, specific voices often break out. The show’s history is full of players who felt like question marks in September but were indispensable by February.
The risks are creative whiplash and growing pains. A stripped-back pre-tape pipeline can hurt weeks when the live sketches don’t fully land. Early episodes might feature more “good ideas, messy execution” desk pieces as the room calibrates. The counterweight is structural continuity—Update, veteran anchors, and writers who know how to steer a wobbly show into a strong final 20 minutes.
What to watch over the first six weeks:
-
A breakout character or duo. Every “new era” needs a memeable hook. Watch the rookies for a lightning-strike recurring bit, especially from Slowikowska or Culhane, who arrive with character-first toolkits.
-
Ben Marshall’s transition. Does his voice migrate from pre-tapes to live sketch with the same snap? If so, expect fast elevation in airtime.
-
The pre-tape identity post-PDD. Look for a new short-film sensibility to surface—sometimes a director/writer pairing becomes the new house style.
-
JAJ’s political load. With a packed news cycle, his impressions will anchor multiple cold opens; how the writers build worlds around those impressions will shape the season’s feel.
.jpg)
The big picture: SNL’s renewal loop is working as designed
If Season 50 was a “victory lap,” Season 51 is the “new muscle” phase—painful at times, thrilling at others. Ending the “Please Don’t Destroy” video era is more than a staffing note; it’s a creative inflection point. SNL is betting that a rebalanced cast, a couple of high-ceiling rookies, and a continued commitment to live, character-driven comedy will keep the show culturally central—on your TV at 11:30 p.m. and on your phone at 8:00 a.m. the next morning.
Circle October 4, 2025 on your calendar. A lot is changing on SNL—but that’s exactly how the show stays SNL.
Keywords: SNL Season 51, Saturday Night Live cast changes, Please Don’t Destroy, Ben Marshall, new SNL cast members, SNL premiere October 2025, Lorne Michaels, SNL writers departures, Weekend Update, Studio 8H.
.jpg)
.jpg)
0 Comments